Pages

Welcome to the World of Shakespeare. Please fasten your seatbelts ladies and gentlemen, sit back, and enjoy the ride! PS: Please keep hands and feet inside of the vehicle at all times. ;)

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Blame my face - the Psychological of Ugly

So last week, as we were discussing Richard III in my group, we got on the topic of his deformities. Apparently, Richard was a  very unattractive man. At least, that's what Shakespeare portrays him as.
 
This reminded me of another character who was famous for being unattractive, The Phantom of the Opera. The Phantom murdered, kidnapped, blackmailed, stalked...he wasn't the best example for the kids, let's just say that. It got me to wondering. Are evil characters merely portrayed as ugly? So that their outward appearance is a manifestation of their inner character? Or do they feel pushed to behave in such a way because of the way others react to their appearance? In the Phantom of the Opera, towards the end of the movie the Phantom blames his actions on the fact that the world has treated him badly because of his deformity.


I was researching this topic when I found an interesting article on the study of crime here. According to the article, the idea of a connection between crime and certain physical characteristics has been a topic of interest for many men. "The physiognomist Johann Kaspar Lavater (1741–1801) was one of the first to suggest a link between facial figures and crime [1]. Victor Hugo referred to his work in Les Misérables, about what he would have said about Thénardier's face. Franz Joseph Gall then developed in 1810 his work on craniology, in which he alleged that crime was one of the behaviors organically controlled by a specific area of the brain. The philosopher Jacob Fries (1773–1843) also suggested a link between crime and physical appearance when he published a criminal anthropology handbook in 1820." The article continues stating that the idea that certain characteristics evidence evil is quite dangerous. The article mentions the fact that this very thing occured in WWII with the Nazi regime. 


It is a very interesting theory. What compels some men and women to such atrocious acts that we'd shudder to even think of them? Could it possibly be a mental imbalance/deformity? And if so, is there any possibility that this could be manifested physically in any way?


Or think of school shootings. Most of the perpetrators are those who felt looked down upon and spurned by their fellow students. This extreme ostracism essentially pushed them to their breaking point, pushed them to murder. Could the psychological effects of this push ordinary people to heinous acts?


It's an interesting concept. 

We are told to never judge a book by it's cover. I still agree with this concept! Beauty is a subjective thing. Different people have different views on what is attractive and what is not. I mean, I don't think Justin Bieber is attractive at all, but there are hordes of girls who would tackle me for saying so (my sister being on of them...), The conclusion that I come to is that the Golden Rule is truly golden, and for a reason! We need to treat people in a manner we'd want to be treated. Be a friend to everyone, cause we never know what a person is going through at any point in time. Who knows, if someone ventured to give Richard or the Phantom a hug once in a while, maybe they would've turned out to be completely productive members of society. ;)

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
It is an interesting idea. I like the comparison between Phantom and Richard... as I was totally confused by Lady Anne, but I feel like I've heard people say they thought Christine ought to have gone with the Phantom rather than her Frenchy Noble.
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
Well, I personally think Lady Anne was a nut job for going with Richard, but I do kind of like Christine with the Phantom rather than Frenchy. haha
"It got me to wondering. Are evil characters merely portrayed as ugly?"

That reminded me of something Sebastian Horsley once said:

"Clearly God loves ugly people. He makes so many of them. He shows his contempt for life by the kind of person he selects to receive it. Crawling from primeval waters you waddled, slaves, cripples, imbeciles, the simple and the mighty, fighting for the right to breathe oxygen. It was a mistake but you did it. Little did it matter to you that the earth was a vale of tears, of horrid sufferings, of torturous sickness and death. You wanted life little worm. You got it."

This blog entry ventures into some terribly un-PC territory. I loved it.
6 replies · active 739 weeks ago
haha well from time to time, un-PC topics need to be considered! I mean, those are generally the ones that garner the most attention anyhow right? Thanks for the comment!
Oh, I quite agree. Conversation is hardly worth having if it isn't offending someone.
btw, that quote is interesting. where did you hear it? that guy must've been having quite the bad day! haha
Sebastian Horsley is a personal hero of sorts—for all the wrong reasons. He was a complete train wreck of a person, a self professed dandy, and a fairly entertaining writer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sebastian_Horsley
Man, you are right. Guy is crazy! haha. He did pretty much the opposite of everything a good upstanding citizen should do. haha. But, i have to admit, his home life and childhood were intense. what did he write about? did he mainly deal with the shock factor?
Haha yeah. Horrible life, incredibly intriguing read. He wrote almost exclusively about himself—what else would rich men with enormous egos and far too much time on their hands do? Here's his autobiography: http://www.amazon.com/Dandy-Underworld-Unauthoriz...

It's fairly entertaining. He's basically Oscar Wilde if Oscar Wilde were straight and did lots of heroin.
I really like that you mentioned this. I remember watching a movie where there was this ugly villain, and my friend Lauren said, "Of course he's ugly! He's the bad guy!" And I thought that was soo sad! Personally, some of the worst people I have known have been really good looking! Just sayin.
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
I agree. No matter what we say, we all tend to judge based on appearance to some degree. But it's true. Outer appearance sometimes hides the most hideous inner person.
I feel like people with deformities in stories are depicted as evil, but I couldn't think of a single real life deformed evil person. I recently saw an incredibly sad movie, the Elephant Man. He is extremely deformed, but he is the exact opposite of the phantom or Richard III, in that he is really kind despite the fact he had been treated terribly. I feel like deformities is a literary cop-op or excuse for making characters terrible people.
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
I agree. I think it's just a tool that authors use sometimes to make it easier to identify the good guy vs. the bad guy.
Good observation. This would be an interesting topic for a research paper. I definitely agree with the idea that people do bad things due to the way others have treated them. This is one of the main problems with our society. We are given these "models" of what people should look like, with celebrities and socialites, and when someone doesn't meet these ridiculous expectations we deem them outcasts and treat them poorly.
Cara Call's avatar

Cara Call · 739 weeks ago

Cesare Lombroso (1835 -1909) wrote a book on this, it is an interesting idea and his book influenced many people including Conrad in his writing of the Secret agent. However, we decided in my 295 class that this not true. It would be interesting to see some scientific evidence.
Being ugly can certainly be a hardship - and it does effect the way you act, because it effects the way people treat you. But just because he wasn't attractive, doesn't give him license to go around killing people. There are plenty of beautiful people who did terrible things, and there are plenty of deformed people who do wonderful things.
I have an aunt who was in a car accident about 18 years ago. She has had multiple plastic surgeries, but she will never really be 'beautiful' (at least by fashion magazine standers - and who is anyways?) She could have hated the world and herself, but she didn't. She ended up going back to school and getting a masters degree and then teaching failing high school students. she 'saved' probably more lives than Richard III ever destroyed.
So yes, physical deformity is something serious, but he shouldn't be using it as an excuse. It's about character, not appearance.
- just a thought
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
I agree that the way you look doesn't predispose you to a way of life. I was just interested in how the psychological impact of feeling like an outcast affects a person. But I totally agree with what you are saying. There is no excuse!

Post a new comment

Comments by